I've also been looking for a new tent to replace my 15 year old Sierra Designs Comet (3 person tent). My Comet has served me very well on countless nights and through some very severe weather, and is still a good functioning tent that will probably last for a couple more years but is beginning to show signs of wear. I also want something with a smaller footprint so I've decided on a 2 person tent.
A few features are important to me -- two doors is a must, I hate crawling over someone to get in and out of the tent. It must have a good amount of vestible area for storing gear. I tend to sleep a bit warm so I like a tent with good ventilation. I also want something that is a bit roomy -- the thought of having just enough room to put a sleeping pad doesn't appeal to me.
I've narrowed my search to 3 tents.
The MSR Hubba Hubba looks like a very nice tent -- the only downside I can see to it is that it's virtually all mesh, which would be great in the summer months but may be a bit on the cool side in the colder spring and fall months when temps are down. The price is about $380.00.
---
The Sierra Designs Electron and with it's near vertical walls is very roomy. I'm familiar with the excellent quality of Sierra Design products and wouldn't hesitate to purchase another of their tents. Price is in the $400.00 range.
---
The Mountain Hardwear Hammerhead 2 has two doors, lots of mesh and has the added bonus of solid panels that zip over the mesh in colder weather. It also has fairly large vestible storage on both doors. It's a little bit heavier than other 2 person tents but since I'm not packing it on my back, weight is not so important. Price is also in the $400.00 range.
---
The MH Hammerhead 2 is very high on my list and will probably be the one that I purchase.
If you're looking for something that is not quite as expensive, MEC offers some pretty
reasonably priced 3 season tents with the Tarn 2 (only 1 door), the hummingbird (also 1 door), and the Wanderer 2 -- these tents are in the $200.00 range.
I really like gear.
*****