OK I want to refrase my question ( or maybe should i just repost this as a new question under a better heading).
We have a new waterfront property in Preedy Harbour on Thetis Island. I have several touring kayaks and have done a lot of wilderness kayaking and hope to continue to do so. I do not bring my dog on wilderness overnight trips. I am really happy with my current touring boat. I am planning to do more day trips and am getting a lot of visitors. Many visitors are inexperienced in kayaks, lots of kids, and just lots of guests. I also have a beloved 50 pound dog, that is great in boats and I want to paddle with from time to time. He is not really suitable in any of my touring boats.
I am wanting to upgrade my fleet by selling one of my touring boats and to replace it with a bigger, stable kayak that friends can use when visiting. ( bigger men cannot use any of my current boats).
I also want to add to the fleet, something like a canoe, or recreational kayak, Sit on top, Folbot ? ( any other ideas are welcome) that I can use for families with kids, for me and my dog to solo paddle, maybe to carry a crab trap, for day trips. This would be used for trips in mainly good weather. Examples would be to go to Tent Island from Preedy Harbour for a picnic, swim , with a group of folks in a variety of boats likely.
I was initially thinking about getting a canoe, but have no experience of using a canoe in the sea, and am less skilled in a canoe.
So first question is what experience with canoes do folks have in gulf island like waters? Would a canoe be able to keep up with people in touring boats? Second question is are SIt on tops ( another idea) unrealistic in our cold waters? How about a recreational kayak ?
Do you have any specific suggestions of boats I should look at?
Thanks for all the suggestions so far, and maybe leave the discussion about the pros and cons of dogs in the wilderness on a different forum? I bring a leash when i have the dog on shore. He has a life jacket. I pack out dog poo. and am not taking him on big wilderness adventures.
Thanks
Kate